Have you ever used real nuru gel from japan? It's edible and made from some time of seaweed extract. I've only seen the fake stuff with additives in the us and can't read Japanese so I. Japan I've gotten similar stuff but never found the true sea weed liquid
So I feel kinda bad cause you are grossed out (I thought the gunge was custard / applesauce or oatmeal), but I'm also kinda turned on by your expression too. It's like Half a hard on? Is that a thing?
I feel like one pie to the face isn't enough to cover up your face abs isn't enough punishment! I'm thinking buckets of marshmallow fluff, cake frosting, and oatmeal / brownie batter would be a better punishment / help cover your face up lolz!